As Hurricane Irene approached, I checked the websites of four decent-sized Presbyterian churches in our area to see what decision they had reached regarding worship services on that Sunday. To my surprise, two of the churches had no mention of Irene through the entire weekend - despite learning through other means that they, like most every church in our area, had cancelled services for the safety of our congregants and at the request of local authorities who did not want non-essential cars on the road.
In this day and age, there is no excuse for a stagnant, out of date website. Almost everyone who visits our church looked us up online before visiting. Your site should look as if it gets an update of some kind every single week. Period. I don't know what you think is more important than updating your site, but it isn't. /rant off